Blog

WHAT PEOPLE WANT ep-06: What Reddit Says About You

By Juyel Rana · November 19, 2026 · Updated November 19, 2026

WHAT PEOPLE WANT ep-06: What Reddit Says About You

Someone in your city opened Reddit last week and typed a question you've answered a hundred times in person: who's actually good for this, nearby, and worth the money?

A few strangers answered. One of them named a business. Maybe it was yours. Maybe it was the competitor two streets over. Either way, you never saw the thread, nobody tagged you, and no alert went off — because there was nothing set up to tell you.

That's the part most small businesses still haven't caught up with. The recommendation didn't happen on Google, and it didn't happen on your website. It happened in a thread, and then it kept working after the thread went quiet, because that's where the machines go looking now.

The recommendation moved somewhere you can't see it

Ask around and you'll hear the same shift from every direction. BrightLocal's 2026 survey found 45% of consumers now use ChatGPT and other AI tools for local recommendations. A year earlier, that figure was 6%. That's not a slow trend; that's a habit changing in twelve months.

And when those AI tools answer, they lean heavily on community threads. Reddit is the most cited domain on Perplexity and sits in the top three for Google AI Mode. Roughly one in five off-page citations across sectors traces back to Reddit. Google has even started pulling Reddit threads straight into Google Business Profiles, so a subreddit debate about your shop can show up next to your address and opening hours, whether you took part in it or not.

Here's the bit that should worry you a little: ChatGPT named a specific local business in only about 1.2% of location-based queries in one analysis, against nearly 36% of businesses appearing in Google's local three-pack. Getting recommended by an assistant is far harder than ranking in Maps. And the threads that decide it are usually small — most cited Reddit posts in one large study had fewer than 20 upvotes and 20 comments, and more than half came from plain question-and-answer threads. One honest customer answering a neighbour's question can carry more weight than your entire services page.

The ten-minute check most owners have never done

You don't need a tool for the first look. You need ten minutes and a search box.

Search site:reddit.com "your business name" and read what comes back. Then search "best [your service] [your city] reddit" — the way a customer would. Then open your city subreddit and search your trade inside it: plumber, dentist, roofer, café, whatever you do. Three searches, and you'll know which of these is true: people praise you, people complain about your whole industry, a competitor gets named instead of you, or there's nothing at all.

Nothing at all is the most common result, and it's not good news. Silence means the assistants have nothing of yours to quote, so they quote whoever the threads do mention. You're not losing an argument. You're not in the room.

Free ways to keep watching, once you know it matters

If the check turns up something worth watching, set up a tripwire instead of re-checking by hand.

Google Alerts is free and still works for your business name and your trade plus your city. F5Bot has a free tier that emails you when a keyword appears on Reddit or Hacker News. For Hacker News specifically, the Algolia search at hn.algolia.com is free, and hnrss.org turns any search there into an RSS feed you can follow. None of this costs anything, and together it covers the places where a mention of you is most likely to appear first.

There's also an open-source route if you like running things yourself: AI Chat Watch is a free CLI tool that runs a set of questions across ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity and reports which brands get mentioned and which sources get cited. It needs your own API key and a little setup, so it's for the tinkerer, not the busy shop owner — but it shows how cheap this has become. What used to be a hundred-dollar-a-month monitoring subscription is now a free alert and a weekend script.

Showing up without getting roasted

Finding the conversation is the easy half. The hard half is joining it without the community deciding you're spam.

A few rules that actually hold up:

Answer as the owner, openly, when you can genuinely help. The highest-value thing you can do in a local thread is explain something well — how pricing works in your trade, what a fair quote looks like, the mistake people make before they call you. People remember the expert who explained things. They screenshot the salesperson.

Never fake it. Don't buy upvotes, don't hire someone to post praise, and don't ask only happy customers for reviews while steering unhappy ones away. The FTC's fake-review rule has been in force since October 2024, and beyond the legal risk, getting caught staging praise on Reddit is the kind of thing that follows a business for years. Threads have a long shelf life in search. A bad look there costs more than any single job is worth.

Let real customers do the talking. The threads AI tools quote most are ordinary people answering a question. That means the work is mostly offline: do good work, and when a happy customer mentions they found you through a recommendation, it's fair to ask them to share that experience where people are asking. You can't script what they write. That's exactly why it counts.

Keep the basics strong anyway. Your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and your website still feed the same assistants. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking, and BrightLocal's survey found 68% of consumers want four stars or more, and 80% are more likely to use a business that answers all its reviews. The community thread and the review profile aren't two separate jobs. They're the same reputation, seen from two sides.

What won't fix this

A prettier website won't. Ranking first on Google won't, on its own — only about 38% of AI Overview citations now come from pages in Google's top ten, down from roughly 76% a year before. The assistants are reading past your site to see what other people say about you. If the answer is nothing, no amount of on-page work fills that gap.

That's uncomfortable, because it's the one part of your visibility you don't control. But it's also the most honest part of the whole system. You can't buy your way into a stranger's recommendation. You can only earn it, and then make sure you're listening when it happens.

So do the ten-minute check this week. If you find a thread about your trade in your city, read it before you do anything else. It will tell you more about what your customers actually want than any keyword report will — because it's them, saying it, in their own words, to each other.

Keep reading on heyjuyel.com

Sources