WHAT PEOPLE WANT ep-04: Get Recommended, Not Just Cited
By Juyel Rana · November 13, 2026 · Updated November 13, 2026

Picture this. A founder runs a small CRM built for solo founders. For a year and a half, her site has sat at number one on Google for the exact query her buyers type. Backlinks, FAQ schema, the lot. Then one evening she asks ChatGPT for the best CRM for a solo founder, and the answer lists five tools. Hers isn't one of them. Her biggest competitor is at the top.
That story has been doing the rounds in founder and SEO circles this month, and it hits a nerve because it's not one person's bad luck. It's the gap between two different games: ranking on Google, and getting recommended by an AI assistant. Winning the first no longer guarantees anything in the second.
Being known isn't the same as being picked
A study of 112 startups put numbers on the gap. ChatGPT recognised 99.4% of them by name when asked directly. But when it was asked to recommend the best tool in a category, it picked only 3.3% of them. Thirty to one. The model knew the products existed. It just didn't think they were worth naming.
That's a strange feeling if you've spent years doing SEO properly. You did the work, you earned the ranking, and the new gatekeeper shrugs. The uncomfortable part is that the gatekeeper isn't being unfair. It's doing what it was built to do: repeat what the open web already says about you, not what your own site says about you.
What actually moves the needle
The same study looked at what predicted a recommendation. The strongest signal was other people mentioning the brand on Reddit. Next came other sites linking to it. Product Hunt upvotes helped a bit too. And here's the part that should change how you spend your time: how well a startup's own pages were formatted for AI — the whole on-page GEO checklist — showed no meaningful correlation at all.
Other research points the same way. Across large citation studies, third-party mentions keep coming out ahead of anything you control on your own site. One analysis found brands need to show up in at least three independent sources before AI engines start naming them with any consistency. Your own website, however polished, counts as one voice. And one voice isn't a consensus.
That explains the founder's screenshot. Her competitor hadn't out-SEO'd her. It had been talked about far more, by far more people, in far more places. Eleven Reddit mentions against thousands. The AI wasn't choosing the better product. It was reporting the louder reputation.
The Reddit shortcut that doesn't work
Naturally, people tried to game this. Marketers have been seeding Reddit posts for clients, answering real buyer questions and dropping the brand name where it seemed to fit. In July, one agency wrote twenty such posts for a startup and waited. ChatGPT still didn't cite or recommend the client. The top reply on the thread where they asked why was blunt: twenty posts from one push read as one source, and AI systems lean on what many independent sources say.
There's a second catch. Which engine your buyers use changes everything. Tests from October found Google's AI Overviews citing Reddit in about half of shopping questions, while ChatGPT's search cited no forum threads at all in the same tests. So a Reddit push aimed at the wrong engine is effort spent in the wrong room. Know where your buyers actually ask.
What to do about it this week
Stop treating AI visibility as a formatting job and start treating it as a reputation job. That's the shift, and it's mostly unglamorous work.
First, ask the question your buyers ask. Type it into ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Mode, and write down who gets named. Not who ranks — who gets named. That's your real scoreboard now, and most businesses have never looked at it.
Second, get talked about where your buyers already compare options. Answer questions in the communities they use, properly and without a pitch. Get listed on the comparison pages and directories in your niche. Ask happy customers to mention you by name in reviews, not just to leave five stars. Each of those is a small, independent voice, and the count is what matters.
Third, check the boring basics. Make sure the AI crawlers — GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot — can actually read your site. Make sure your own pages state the facts about your business clearly: what you do, who it's for, where you're based. If the engine can't read you, it can't describe you correctly, and a wrong description is worse than none.
And fourth, be patient with it in a way SEO never asked you to be. A backlink shows up in a report next week. A reputation builds over months of people saying your name in rooms you don't control. That's slow, and there's no plugin for it. But it's also the part nobody can copy overnight, which is exactly why it works.
Keep reading on heyjuyel.com
- Ranking on Google Doesn't Mean ChatGPT Will Cite You
- How to Get Cited by AI Search in 2026: A Practical GEO Playbook for Small Businesses
- Google Replaced Your Knowledge Panel With an AI Overview
- 35 Modern SEO Hacks for AI Overviews and LLM Citations in 2026
- The Zero Click KPI Set for 2026
Sources
- Ask HN: Does your website show up when ChatGPT recommends tools in your field?
- ChatGPT Cited My Competitor, Not Me: An Honest Diagnosis
- How can ChatGPT recommend my business? What the tests show about who gets suggested
- We Posted on Reddit for GEO and Nothing Happened: Why Seeded Posts Don't Move AI Answers
- How to Get Your Startup Cited by ChatGPT
- AI Search Rewrites You. Get Named Anyway.
Want help getting named?
If ChatGPT keeps recommending your competitors while you do the actual work, that's fixable — but it starts with knowing where you stand. Get a free SEO audit and I'll check how AI search describes your business, who it names instead of you, and what to do first.
